On the North Shore pie trail: from Killara to Waverton
In the latest addition to our North Shore pie series, we sampled rat coffins from Killara Bakery and The Grumpy Bakery, Waverton
Huw Bradshaw
October 14, 2025
Upper North Shore versus Lower… Waverton up against Killara … who bakes the best pie? Watch below to find out.
Killara Bakery Cafe and Groceries — East Killara
The Grumpy Baker — Waverton
The story so far…
S TIER
Breadworks Cafe — McMahons Point — 9.5/10
A TIER
-
B TIER
Cornucopia Bakery — Naremburn — 8/10
Killara Bakery — East Killara — 8/10
Romeo’s Pie Cafe — St Leonards — 7.5/10
C TIER
The Grumpy Baker — Waverton — 6/10
D TIER
-